A Fatal Grace

A Fatal Grace

Large Print - 2012
Average Rating:
Rate this:
"No one liked CC de Poitiers -- not her family, not her lover, not her neighbors in Three Pines. When Chief Inspector Armand Gamache is called to investigate CC's sudden death on the day after Christmas, it seems like an impossible murder. How could she have been lectrocuted in the middle of a frozen lake in the midst of Three Pines annual curling match without anyone seeing a thing? In the beautiful but deadly Quebec winter, Gamache digs for secrets beneath the surface of village life. But something more chilling than the bitter wind is coming for him"--P. [4] of cover.
Publisher: Waterville, Maine : Thorndike Press, 2012
Copyright Date: ©2006
ISBN: 9781410449245
Characteristics: 557 pages (large print) ; 23 cm
Call Number: LT PENNY, L


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment
Jan 14, 2019

always a great writer.

Nov 30, 2018

The second book in the series, and even though it is not among her best, Penny is so far above most mystery writers that it is still outstanding within the genre. She's really just getting started here, folks.

Sep 18, 2018

This is the second book in Louise Penny’s series, though not the second of hers I have read. As usual, she chose an interesting tidbit to weave throughout the story. This time, it was the art of painting the inside of a glass ball to create a luminously beautiful Christmas ornament. The villain of the story, CC de Poitiers, named her “philosophy” after this technique; she advocated repressing and denying all emotions, keeping them “inside.” CC herself was particularly suited to this practice, as she was universally disliked by all, including her husband and child, her lover, all the inhabitants of Three Pines, and the reader. She was electrocuted during a curling match (really!) and Gamache sprang into action, ascertaining that it was a homicide rather than an accident as was initially believed. He schooled the smart-ass young upstarts who disrespected his thoughtful approach to investigating the event, figured out the killer, handled the case compassionately toward all, and won everyone over in the end, of course.

Mar 06, 2018

Only a Canadian could write a novel about murder at a curling rink!

Mar 02, 2018

The first book or 2 I read of Louise Penny’s seemed enjoyable enough. As I have twice tried to read a couple more, I cannot stand the sarcasm. I’m not sure what she has against God and religious denominations, but she sure is cynical. I don’t really care for her vulgar humor either. Guess she will be struck from my list of authors to follow.

Sep 05, 2017

I saw a TV interview with Louise Penny and thought I'd give her books a try. I am reading the 3rd one and am enjoying them. Not over the top excellent writing, but intriguing story lines. I described it to a relative as sort of 'Nancy Drew or Hardy Boys' for adults.

Enjoyable reading.

Aug 28, 2017

While I enjoyed the first book in the series (Still Life), I found this one more entertaining, at least in the writing. The plot is satisfyingly complex, although I found the solution to the murder a little too much of a stretch. I usually avoid mysteries that are marketed as "laugh out loud" funny, and even though this one isn't like that, some of the dialogue was pretty witty -- maybe Louise Penny needs to write screenplays and infuse some intelligence back into the movie world.

ArapahoeNancy May 01, 2017

This is the first book that I have read by Louise Penny. The book takes place in Three Pines a small town in Quebec, Canada. Inspector Armand Gamache is called to the town to investigate the murder of an unpopular author that recently moved to the town. Just about everyone has a motive to kill. This book kept me turning the pages to find out the answer.

rb3221 Apr 06, 2017

Lots of intrigue and suspense with a few unexpected twists. This is a fascinating mystery with an ending that may surprise some readers yet the murder itself is somewhat bizarre and implausible. I especially enjoy Gamache's style as not your usual detective but rather one who talks to the residents of Three Pines to get to know these vividly portrayed, fully explored characters. This is his quiet and efficient way of solving the murder.
Will the next book let us know what is happening to the generally disliked Yvette Nicol and will we discover the unresolved mysteries surrounding Gamache's past with the Arnot case? An entertaining and very satisfying read and onto the next one. I am enjoying the series.

PimaLib_ChristineR Feb 01, 2017

The second Gamache novel again finds the inspector in Three Pines, a small village, off the map, with a higher than average chance that the residents will wind up dead. Not the best of the series, but like Murder on the Orient Express, there are too many suspects and a corpse over whom no one will mourn.

View All Comments


Add a Quote
Oct 01, 2018

“But it wasn’t the stage that petrified Crie, nor was it the audience. It was what wasn’t there that had stopped her dead in her tracks.
Crie knew from long experience it was always the things you didn’t see that were the scariest.
And what Crie didn’t see broke her heart.”

Oct 01, 2018

“But it wasn’t the stage that petrified Crie, nor was it the audience. It was what wasn’t there that had stopped her dead in her tracks.
Crie knew from long experience it was always the things you didn’t see that were the scariest.
And what Crie didn’t see broke her heart.”

PimaLib_SamR Mar 07, 2016

We become our beliefs.

Aug 25, 2015

"Oh, she wasn't very good, but she wasn't so bad either. I mean, really, who isn't cruel and selfish?" Ruth Zardo, the old poet, referring to CC de Poitiers, p 78.

Aug 25, 2015

"All I have to do is keep throwing light in front of me, and follow the headlights. Eventually I'll get there." Gamache, p 163.

Jul 11, 2014

"All the mistakes I've made have been because I've assumed something and then acted as though it was a fact."
Inspector Gamache.


Add a Summary
Sep 30, 2018

CC de Poitiers is electrocuted in front of a crowd at the big event . . .

Feb 16, 2012

This is the same book as "A Fatal Grace" but different title.


Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at DCL

To Top